diff --git a/MantidQt/MantidWidgets/src/InstrumentView/InstrumentWidgetPickTab.cpp b/MantidQt/MantidWidgets/src/InstrumentView/InstrumentWidgetPickTab.cpp
index 5adbf358c48724593caf5c53f214c73858dc1913..ca4f5b34b0b1ecb231a05c5b9984a0e88b02e67e 100644
--- a/MantidQt/MantidWidgets/src/InstrumentView/InstrumentWidgetPickTab.cpp
+++ b/MantidQt/MantidWidgets/src/InstrumentView/InstrumentWidgetPickTab.cpp
@@ -240,7 +240,7 @@ InstrumentWidgetPickTab::InstrumentWidgetPickTab(InstrumentWidget *instrWidget)
   m_peakCompare = new QPushButton();
   m_peakCompare->setCheckable(true);
   m_peakCompare->setAutoExclusive(true);
-  m_peakCompare->setIcon(QIcon(":/PickTools/selection-peaks.png"));
+  m_peakCompare->setIcon(QIcon(":/PickTools/selection-peak-compare.png"));
   m_peakCompare->setToolTip("Compare single crystal peak(s)");
 
   QGridLayout *toolBox = new QGridLayout();
diff --git a/images/MantidWidgets.qrc b/images/MantidWidgets.qrc
index 6e9a5539844aac37f509e6223cdfb5727743cbf5..c97782b14ccad8890ecb4214abeca49615d108b9 100644
--- a/images/MantidWidgets.qrc
+++ b/images/MantidWidgets.qrc
@@ -13,6 +13,7 @@
         <file>selection-box-ring.png</file>
         <file>selection-circle-ring.png</file>
         <file>brush.png</file>
+        <file>selection-peak-compare.png</file>
     </qresource>
     <qresource prefix="/MaskTools">
         <file>selection-circle.png</file>
diff --git a/images/selection-peak-compare.png b/images/selection-peak-compare.png
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..84deb3f07c359729f811d339db5b54933eed0eb3
Binary files /dev/null and b/images/selection-peak-compare.png differ