Commit e0a5c761 authored by Uria Martinez, Rocio's avatar Uria Martinez, Rocio
Browse files

- Updated data input files to include exogenous credit projections for WA CFS 

data.gms
-Reset marine biofuels defaults to 15% blends with heavy fuel oil and available feedstock credits for SLD an MNR
-Inclusion of exogenous credits for WA CFS
-Changed nomenclature for the two options of CA LCFS/ OR CFP/ WA CFS policy settings to "Baseline_Policy" and "High_Policy_Support"

main.gms
-Changed nomenclature for the two options of CA LCFS/ OR CFP/ WA CFS policy settings to "Baseline_Policy" and "High_Policy_Support"
-Removed unused parameter AEO_TRA_Fuel_Usage_Adjust

summ.gms
-Changed calculations of domestic biofuel production to be done right at biorefinery gate. The previous approach calculated them in the next activity (easier because it is already in gallons) which results in potential undercounting production (if there is excess supply, if there are multiple potential destinations for the biofuel such as in the case of corn ethanol)
parent 429072a8

BioTrans_p.gdx

−10.2 KiB (10.1 MiB)

File changed.

No diff preview for this file type.

View original file
View changed file

data.gms

+21 −22
Original line number Diff line number Diff line
@@ -401,8 +401,8 @@ MNR_FDSTCK_CRED "Feedstock credit for wastewater sludge collected for a 
;



*Adjustment to include/exclude feedstock credits (representative of avoided disposal/management fees) for sludge and manure.

*OMC("HDL_SLD_B", R, T) = OMC("HDL_SLD_B", R, T) - SLD_FDSTCK_CRED;

*OMC("HDL_MNR_B", R, T) = OMC("HDL_MNR_B", R, T) - MNR_FDSTCK_CRED;

OMC("HDL_SLD_B", R, T) = OMC("HDL_SLD_B", R, T) - SLD_FDSTCK_CRED;

OMC("HDL_MNR_B", R, T) = OMC("HDL_MNR_B", R, T) - MNR_FDSTCK_CRED;



SCALAR

BIOREFANNFACTOR          "Annualization factor" /15.5/
@@ -829,8 +829,8 @@ JFL_DEM_P 1 


BOL_PYR_B          -1

BOL_TRA_T           1         -1.9611

BOL_MIX_T                       1        -0.26734

RFL_MIX_T                                -0.62739

BOL_MIX_T                       1        -0.13367

RFL_MIX_T                                -0.75746

P15_BLN_T                                   1          -1

P15_TRA_P                                               1           -1

RFO_DEM_P                                                            1
@@ -975,22 +975,22 @@ RFSREQ_Case(AEOCase, RFSfuture, "RFS_CELL", T)$THIST(T) = 0; 


TABLE LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat, R, LCFSfuture, T)  "LCFS/CFPs carbon intensity benchmarks by fuel pool (gCO2e/MJ), by state, by case"

                                     2020   2021   2022   2023   2024   2025   2026   2027   2028   2029   2030   2031   2032   2033   2034   2035   2036   2037   2038   2039   2040   2041   2042   2043   2044   2045   2046   2047   2048   2049   2050   

LCFS_GAS.CA.LCFS_Base     91.98  90.74  89.50  88.25  87.01  85.77  84.52  83.28  82.04  80.80  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55

LCFS_DES.CA.LCFS_Base     92.92  91.66  90.41  89.15  87.89  86.64  85.38  84.13  82.87  81.62  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36

LCFS_JET.CA.LCFS_Base     89.37  89.37  89.37  89.15  87.89  86.64  85.38  84.13  82.87  81.62  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36

LCFS_GAS.CA.LCFS_Proposed 91.98  90.74  89.50  88.25  87.01  76.60  75.16  73.72  72.28  70.84  69.40  64.94  60.48  56.02  51.55  47.09  42.63  38.17  33.71  29.24  24.78  21.81  18.83  15.86  12.88   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91

LCFS_DES.CA.LCFS_Proposed 92.92  91.66  90.41  89.15  87.89  81.70  80.17  78.63  77.10  75.57  74.03  69.27  64.51  59.75  54.99  50.23  45.47  40.71  35.95  31.19  26.44  23.26  20.09  16.92  13.74  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57

LCFS_JET.CA.LCFS_Proposed 89.37  89.37  89.37  89.15  87.89  81.70  80.17  78.63  77.10  75.57  74.03  69.27  64.51  59.75  54.99  50.23  45.47  40.71  35.95  31.19  26.44  23.26  20.09  16.92  13.74  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57

LCFS_GAS.OR.LCFS_Base     95.6   94.6   93.2   91.7   90.2   88.3   86.3   84.3   82.4   80.4   78.5   75.1   71.8   68.5   65.1   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8   61.8

LCFS_DES.OR.LCFS_Base     96.3   95.3   93.8   92.3   90.8   88.9   86.9   84.9   82.9   81.0   79.0   75.6   72.3   68.9   65.6   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   62.2   

LCFS_JET.OR.LCFS_Base     90.8   90.8   90.8   90.8   90.8   88.87  86.89  84.92  82.94  80.97  78.99  75.63  72.28  68.92  65.56  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21  62.21   

LCFS_GAS.WA.LCFS_Base                          98.44  97.97  96.95  95.96  94.97  93.49  92.00  90.52  89.04  89.04  89.04  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14    

LCFS_DES.WA.LCFS_Base                          99.61  99.11  98.11  97.11  96.11  94.60  93.10  91.60  90.10  90.10  90.10  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09

LCFS_JET.WA.LCFS_Base                          99.61  99.11  98.11  97.11  96.11  94.60  93.10  91.60  90.10  90.10  90.10  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09

LCFS_GAS.CA.Baseline_Policy         91.98  90.74  89.50  88.25  87.01  85.77  84.52  83.28  82.04  80.80  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55  79.55

LCFS_DES.CA.Baseline_Policy         92.92  91.66  90.41  89.15  87.89  86.64  85.38  84.13  82.87  81.62  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36

LCFS_JET.CA.Baseline_Policy         89.37  89.37  89.37  89.15  87.89  86.64  85.38  84.13  82.87  81.62  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36  80.36

LCFS_GAS.CA.High_Policy_Support     91.98  90.74  89.50  88.25  87.01  76.60  75.16  73.72  72.28  70.84  69.40  64.94  60.48  56.02  51.55  47.09  42.63  38.17  33.71  29.24  24.78  21.81  18.83  15.86  12.88   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91   9.91

LCFS_DES.CA.High_Policy_Support     92.92  91.66  90.41  89.15  87.89  81.70  80.17  78.63  77.10  75.57  74.03  69.27  64.51  59.75  54.99  50.23  45.47  40.71  35.95  31.19  26.44  23.26  20.09  16.92  13.74  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57

LCFS_JET.CA.High_Policy_Support     89.37  89.37  89.37  89.15  87.89  81.70  80.17  78.63  77.10  75.57  74.03  69.27  64.51  59.75  54.99  50.23  45.47  40.71  35.95  31.19  26.44  23.26  20.09  16.92  13.74  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57  10.57

LCFS_GAS.OR.Baseline_Policy         95.61  94.63  93.15  91.68  90.21  88.25  84.92  82.99  81.06  79.13  72.20  73.92  70.64  67.36  64.08  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  60.80  

LCFS_DES.OR.Baseline_Policy         96.27  95.29  93.81  92.32  90.84  88.87  90.40  88.34  86.29  84.24  82.18  78.69  75.20  71.70  68.21  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72 

LCFS_JET.OR.Baseline_Policy         90.80  90.80  90.80  90.80  90.80  88.87  88.21  88.21  86.29  84.24  82.18  78.69  75.20  71.70  68.21  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  64.72  

LCFS_GAS.WA.Baseline_Policy                              98.44  97.97  96.95  95.96  94.97  93.49  92.00  90.52  89.04  89.04  89.04  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14  79.14    

LCFS_DES.WA.Baseline_Policy                              99.61  99.11  98.11  97.11  96.11  94.60  93.10  91.60  90.10  90.10  90.10  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09

LCFS_JET.WA.Baseline_Policy                              99.61  99.11  98.11  97.11  96.11  94.60  93.10  91.60  90.10  90.10  90.10  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09  80.09

;



LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"OR","LCFS_Proposed",T) = LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"OR","LCFS_Base",T);

LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"WA","LCFS_Proposed",T) = LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"WA","LCFS_Base",T);

LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"OR","High_Policy_Support",T) = LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"OR","Baseline_Policy",T);

LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"WA","High_Policy_Support",T) = LCFS_CI_benchmark_cases(LCFSCat,"WA","Baseline_Policy",T);



*Note: Benchmarks in the California Base (Proposed) future are specified by regulation until 2040 (2045) and assumed to remain constant from there to the end of the modeling period.

*For Oregon, benchmarks are specified by regulation until 2035 and assumed constant after that.
@@ -1046,7 +1046,7 @@ MXD_FMW_T 0 1 0 


TABLE LCFS_energycontent(AMIXT, ECCONVFACT) "Energy content by pathway (MJ per gal)"

$ONDELIM

$INCLUDE CALCFS_AMIXT_MJpergal.csv

$INCLUDE LCFS_AMIXT_MJpergal.csv

$OFFDELIM

;
@@ -1063,7 +1063,6 @@ $INCLUDE LCFS_exogcred_energy_all.csv 
$OFFDELIM

;





TABLE LCFS_exogcred_CI_cases(LCFSfuture,EXOGCRD_type,R,T) "Carbon Intensity projections from pathways not endogenously included in BioTrans that generate LCFS/CFP credits, by state, year, and LCFS scenario, (grams of CO2 equivalent per megajoule)"

$ONDELIM

$INCLUDE LCFS_exogcred_CI_all.csv

data_inputs/AMIXT_CI_LCFS_all.csv

+259 −259

File changed.

Preview size limit exceeded, changes collapsed.

data_inputs/LCFS_AMIXT_MJpergal.csv

0 → 100644
+44 −0
Original line number Diff line number Diff line 
"AMIXT","MJpergal"

"MIX_GAS_T",119.53

"MIX_DES_T",134.47

"MIX_PJT_T",142.43256

"MIX_RFL_T",157.931835047619

"MIX_ETH_T",81.51

"MIX_SUG_T",81.51

"MIX_BDS_T",126.13

"MIX_BOL_T",68.13738

"MIX_BDM_T",126.13

"MIX_RDM_T",129.65

"MXS_HFG_T",126.37

"MXS_HSY_T",126.37

"MXS_ACR_T",126.37

"MXS_AST_T",126.37

"MXS_AHE_T",126.37

"MXS_AFR_T",126.37

"MXS_FST_T",126.37

"MXS_FHE_T",126.37

"MXS_FWE_T",126.37

"MXS_FFR_T",126.37

"MXS_FMW_T",126.37

"MXG_HFG_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_HSY_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_ACR_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_AST_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_AHE_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_AFR_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_FST_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_FHE_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_FWE_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_FFR_T",131.831759238095

"MXG_FMW_T",131.831759238095

"MXD_HFG_T",129.65

"MXD_HSY_T",129.65

"MXD_ACR_T",129.65

"MXD_AST_T",129.65

"MXD_AHE_T",129.65

"MXD_AFR_T",129.65

"MXD_FST_T",129.65

"MXD_FHE_T",129.65

"MXD_FWE_T",129.65

"MXD_FFR_T",129.65

"MXD_FMW_T",129.65

data_inputs/LCFS_exogcred_CI_all.csv

+24 −16
Original line number Diff line number Diff line 
"LCFSfuture","EXOGCRD_type","R","2020","2021","2022","2023","2024","2025","2026","2027","2028","2029","2030","2031","2032","2033","2034","2035","2036","2037","2038","2039","2040","2041","2042","2043","2044","2045","2046","2047","2048","2049","2050"

"LCFS_Base","LD_EV","CA",42.64,32.27,37.06,56.98,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94

"LCFS_Base","LD_EV","OR",50.83,33.014,46.444,-2.652,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82

"LCFS_Base","LNG","CA",55,60.3,57,49.2,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1

"LCFS_Base","LNG","OR",55,60.3,57,49.2,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1

"LCFS_Base","MDHD_EV","CA",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"LCFS_Base","MDHD_EV","OR",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"LCFS_Base","RNG","CA",1.9,-43.1,-93.9,-119.8,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1

"LCFS_Base","RNG","OR",64.39,30.36,23.5,-182.57,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333

"LCFS_Proposed","LD_EV","CA",42.64,32.27,37.06,56.98,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94

"LCFS_Proposed","LD_EV","OR",50.83,33.014,46.444,-2.652,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82

"LCFS_Proposed","LNG","CA",55.024060663136,60.2847023010254,56.9832428168938,49.2380939004018,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2

"LCFS_Proposed","LNG","OR",55.024060663136,60.2847023010254,56.9832428168938,49.2380939004018,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2

"LCFS_Proposed","MDHD_EV","CA",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"LCFS_Proposed","MDHD_EV","OR",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"LCFS_Proposed","RNG","CA",1.93088276473752,-43.1096542772202,-93.9341726805216,-119.825581281012,-119.8,-126.581261002204,-141.990259782158,-158.227230383932,-175.780373664741,-196.254127399491,-220.075801946412,-246.610350261995,-273,-273,-273,-273,-218.4,-163.8,-109.2,-54.6,16.6208158997875,15.955983263796,15.3177439332442,14.7050341759144,14.1168328088778,13.5521594965227,13.0100731166618,12.4896701919953,11.9900833843155,11.5104800489429,11.0500608469852

"LCFS_Proposed","RNG","OR",64.39,30.36,23.5,-182.57,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739,-43.5757599383739
 
"Baseline_Policy","LD_EV","CA",42.64,32.27,37.06,56.98,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94

"Baseline_Policy","LD_EV","OR",50.83,33.014,46.444,-2.652,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82

"Baseline_Policy","LD_EV","WA",NA,NA,NA,10.86,10.23,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61

"Baseline_Policy","LNG","CA",55,60.3,57,49.2,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1

"Baseline_Policy","LNG","OR",55,60.3,57,49.2,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1

"Baseline_Policy","LNG","WA",55,60.3,57,49.2,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1,56.1

"Baseline_Policy","MDHD_EV","CA",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"Baseline_Policy","MDHD_EV","OR",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"Baseline_Policy","MDHD_EV","WA",NA,NA,NA,12.5914908482097,12.1405136530435,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125

"Baseline_Policy","RNG","CA",1.9,-43.1,-93.9,-119.8,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1,-88.1

"Baseline_Policy","RNG","OR",64.39,30.36,23.5,-182.57,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333

"Baseline_Policy","RNG","WA",NA,NA,NA,59.59,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67,44.67

"High_Policy_Support","LD_EV","CA",42.64,32.27,37.06,56.98,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94,44.94

"High_Policy_Support","LD_EV","OR",50.83,33.014,46.444,-2.652,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82,21.82

"High_Policy_Support","LD_EV","WA",NA,NA,NA,10.86,10.23,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61,10.61

"High_Policy_Support","LNG","CA",55.024060663136,60.2847023010254,56.9832428168938,49.2380939004018,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2

"High_Policy_Support","LNG","OR",55.024060663136,60.2847023010254,56.9832428168938,49.2380939004018,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2

"High_Policy_Support","LNG","WA",55.024060663136,60.2847023010254,56.9832428168938,49.2380939004018,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2,49.2

"High_Policy_Support","MDHD_EV","CA",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"High_Policy_Support","MDHD_EV","OR",37.1,-21.6,5.7,11.4,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5,2.5

"High_Policy_Support","MDHD_EV","WA",NA,NA,NA,12.5914908482097,12.1405136530435,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125,12.3928864790125

"High_Policy_Support","RNG","CA",1.93088276473752,-43.1096542772202,-93.9341726805216,-119.825581281012,-119.8,-126.581261002204,-141.990259782158,-158.227230383932,-175.780373664741,-196.254127399491,-220.075801946412,-246.610350261995,-273,-273,-273,-273,-218.4,-163.8,-109.2,-54.6,16.6208158997875,15.955983263796,15.3177439332442,14.7050341759144,14.1168328088778,13.5521594965227,13.0100731166618,12.4896701919953,11.9900833843155,11.5104800489429,11.0500608469852

"High_Policy_Support","RNG","OR",64.39,30.36,23.5,-182.57,-42.9033333333333,-42.9033333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333,-40.9933333333333

"High_Policy_Support","RNG","WA",NA,NA,NA,59.59,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88,20.88